A third of Black Friday deals were cheaper before Black Friday
Community

A third of Black Friday deals were cheaper before Black Friday

Angie Beebe
Angie Beebe
·

See more PinScene stories in your Google results.

Shoppers are expected to spend over $1 trillion this season, and more of them are hunting for value. Here's how to know what a good price actually is.

A "doorbuster" isn't always a bargain. In a study of 2,620 products at nine retailers during the 2025 holiday season, about 33% were cheaper earlier in the season than on Black Friday, according to Visualping, a company that sells price-monitoring software. The Black Friday prices on those items were still 37% above their lowest price of the season. Luggage was the worst category, at 61%. It's a vendor study and it included some Canadian retailers, so treat it as a rough guide.

A British consumer group has found the same pattern for years. In its latest check, Which? found 83% of products it tracked were the same price or cheaper at least once outside the four-week sales period.

It matters more this year because money is tight. The National Retail Federation expects November and December sales to grow 4.2%, to $1.013 trillion. In its holiday survey, 56% of shoppers said the economy will affect their spending. About 35% of shoppers are trading down to cheaper alternatives, Salesforce says. In a one-day Penny Hoarder poll of 1,000 adults in August, the average planned holiday spend was $818, and more than three-quarters said they were changing how they buy gifts. Toy prices were up 6.6% over the past year in September, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

When the discounts are deepest. Black Friday is November 27 and Cyber Monday is November 30. Adobe, which tracks online sales, expects discounts of up to 14% in early November and up to 21% just before Thanksgiving. Here's what it forecasts by category:

CategoryExpected peak discountBest day, per Adobe
Electronics30%Cyber Monday
Toys29%Black Friday
TVs23%Black Friday
Computers23%Cyber Monday
Apparel23%Black Friday
Sporting goods19%Thanksgiving
Appliances18%Black Friday
Furniture18%Black Friday

Sales are starting early. Walmart runs an early Black Friday event November 12 to 15, its main Black Friday deals November 23 to 29, and opens stores at 6 a.m. on November 27. Best Buy starts 10 days of doorbusters on November 19. Target opens at 6 a.m. on Black Friday and is closed on Thanksgiving.

Check the price history first. This is the single most useful habit. Amazon now shows up to 365 days of price history on eligible product pages. Google shows price history for many items in its shopping results. Consumer Reports also points shoppers to trackers like CamelCamelCamel and Keepa. If a "50% off" item has sold at that price for months, it isn't a holiday deal.

Be skeptical of the "was" price. Federal Trade Commission guidelines say a former price has to be one the item was really sold at for a substantial period. If it's "an artificial, inflated price," the bargain is a false one. California goes further, generally barring stores from advertising a former price unless it was the prevailing market price within the past three months. Most of the fights happen in court. More than 500 class actions have been filed over reference pricing in the past decade, according to the law firm Ballard Spahr. Countdown timers aren't proof of anything either: in a small check of Etsy listings, US PIRG found 16 of 20 timers simply reset with no change in price.

Use the protections you already have. Target's holiday price match covers Target's own later price drops from November 1 through December 24. Best Buy says it will match its own holiday price drops, and most purchases from October 30 through December 31 can be returned through January 15. If a charge is wrong or an item never arrives, a credit card lets you dispute it under federal law, as long as your letter reaches the issuer within 60 days after the first bill with the error, the FTC says.

Go easy on buy now, pay later. Adobe expects these plans to drive $21.3 billion in online sales this season. They can look like free money, but several small loans add up. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has warned that borrowers can quickly end up with loans at multiple lenders. Late fees run up to $7 at Klarna and up to $8 at Afterpay, while Affirm doesn't charge them, CBS News reported.

Watch your texts. Fake package delivery messages were the most common text scam reported to the FTC in 2024, and scammers lean on them around the holidays. Don't tap links in messages about a delivery you weren't expecting. The Better Business Bureau also warns about gift cards being drained before you use them and online purchase scams. It's the same trick as the unpaid toll text.

Sources

Frequently asked

Are Black Friday deals actually good?

Some are, but many aren't the lowest price of the year. A 2025 study by Visualping found about 33% of tracked items were cheaper earlier in the season, and Which? found 83% matched or beat the sale price at other times.

When are the best Black Friday deals in 2026?

Adobe expects the deepest discounts on electronics and computers on Cyber Monday, November 30, and on TVs, toys, apparel, appliances, and furniture on Black Friday, November 27. Sporting goods discounts are expected to peak on Thanksgiving.

How can I check if a sale price is real?

Look up the price history before you buy. Amazon shows up to 365 days of history on eligible items, Google shows it for many products, and trackers such as CamelCamelCamel and Keepa follow Amazon prices over time.