
Can you cut your neighbor's overhanging tree branches?
See more PinScene stories in your Google results.
The trunk decides who owns a tree. Trimming to the line is usually fine, but harming the tree can cost three times the damages in some states.
You can usually trim a neighbor's branches that hang over your yard, but only up to the property line, and only in a way that doesn't hurt the tree. Go further and a handful of states let your neighbor collect three times their damages.
Tree law is mostly state law plus city rules, so the details depend on where you live. The basics look a lot alike from place to place, though.
Who owns the tree. The trunk decides. In California, a tree whose trunk stands entirely on one person's land belongs to that owner, even when its roots grow next door, under Civil Code Section 833. When the trunk sits on the line, the neighbors own it together, under Section 834. A tree overhang guide from Clark County, Washington, says the same about boundary trees: every owner shares responsibility, and removing one without all of their consent is unlawful.
Trimming what hangs over. You may trim only up to the boundary line, according to the Clark County guide, which draws on FindLaw. If you need to step onto your neighbor's land to do it, get permission first, unless the limbs threaten "imminent and grave harm." You also can't cut the whole tree down or prune it so hard that you ruin its structure or its looks.
That last part is where people get in trouble. In Booska v. Patel (1994), a California appeals court ruled that a homeowner who cut a neighbor's tree roots on his own side of the line could still be liable for the harm to the tree. Owning the land doesn't give you an unlimited right to do anything on it, the court said.
Washington courts have been friendlier to the person holding the saw. In Mustoe v. Ma (2016), a state appeals court let a homeowner cut encroaching roots and branches at the line and declined to create a duty of care toward the neighbor's tree.
Roots, leaves, and fruit. Leaves are treated as natural, so you generally have no claim against the owner even if they clog your gutters, the county guide says. Fruit on the tree belongs to the tree's owner, and courts are split on fruit that has fallen. In most states you can cut back roots yourself, but a lawsuit over roots usually requires serious harm, such as structural damage.
The triple-damages rule. This is what makes tree fights expensive. Several states multiply damages when someone cuts or injures a tree on another person's land without permission:
- California: three times the actual damages under Civil Code Section 3346, or twice the damages if the trespass was casual or involuntary. Code of Civil Procedure Section 733 also allows treble damages.
- Washington: treble damages under RCW 64.12.030, but only single damages if it was casual or involuntary, under RCW 64.12.040.
- Oregon: treble damages for willful injury under ORS 105.810, and a court may add attorney fees and reforestation costs.
- Michigan: three times the actual damages under MCL 600.2919, or single damages if it was casual and involuntary.
The math adds up fast. If an arborist values a mature tree at $5,000, triple damages would be $15,000.
City permits. Even a tree that's entirely yours may need a permit. Los Angeles requires one to remove protected native trees, including most native oaks and the Western sycamore, once they're at least 4 inches wide at 54 inches above the ground, according to TreePeople. Austin bars removing a heritage tree, a listed species 24 inches or more across at 4.5 feet up, except under narrow exceptions, and also regulates protected trees of 19 inches or more. Portland regulates private trees 12 inches or more in diameter. Check your city's rules before anyone cuts a big tree, even with your neighbor's blessing.
When the tree looks dangerous. Tree owners are expected to inspect their trees and keep them safe, Clark County says. If a neighbor's tree looks ready to fall, the guide suggests getting an arborist's report and sending it by certified mail to your neighbor and to your homeowners insurance company. Some cities will remove a hazardous tree or order the owner to do it, and a court can order a tree removed if it finds the tree is a nuisance.
That paper trail matters later. If a tree falls and a reasonable person couldn't have prevented it, it's treated as an act of God, and the neighbor generally isn't liable. A documented warning shows your neighbor was told about the problem.
If it falls anyway. Insurance pays less for trees than most people expect. When a tree hits an insured structure, removal coverage is generally about $500 to $1,000, and there's generally no debris removal coverage if it didn't hit one, according to the Insurance Information Institute. We covered who pays when a neighbor's tree falls in more detail.
Most of these fights start over a few branches. A conversation, an agreement in writing, and an arborist before anyone picks up a saw will prevent nearly all of them.
Sources
- California Civil Code Section 833
- California Civil Code Section 834
- California Civil Code Section 3346
- California Code of Civil Procedure Section 733
- Washington RCW 64.12.030
- Washington RCW 64.12.040
- Oregon ORS 105.810
- Michigan MCL 600.2919
- Clark County, Washington: Tree overhang guide
- Booska v. Patel (1994), California Court of Appeal
- Mustoe v. Ma (2016), Washington Court of Appeals
- TreePeople: Los Angeles protected trees and shrubs
- City of Austin: Tree reviews and permitting
- Portland City Code 11.40.020
- Insurance Information Institute: If a tree falls on your house
Frequently asked
Can I cut my neighbor's tree branches that hang over my yard?
Usually yes, up to the property line, as long as you don't enter their land without permission or damage the tree's health or structure. Cutting too much can make you liable, and some states triple the damages.
Who owns a tree on the property line?
A tree whose trunk sits on the boundary generally belongs to both neighbors together, as in California Civil Code Section 834. They share responsibility for it, and removing it without every owner's consent is generally unlawful.
What happens if I cut down my neighbor's tree?
You can be sued for the tree's value, and several states multiply it. California, Washington, Oregon, and Michigan allow triple damages for cutting or injuring a tree on someone else's land, with lower awards in some states for accidents.
