A record 26% of Americans are spending more than they earned, and the middle class took the biggest hit
Local News

A record 26% of Americans are spending more than they earned, and the middle class took the biggest hit

Angie Beebe
Angie Beebe
·

See more PinScene stories in your Google results.

The share of people outspending their income jumped from 19% to 26% in three years. Middle earners lost the most ground.

More than one in four American adults, 26%, said they spent more money than their income earned in the past year, the highest share since the FINRA Foundation began asking in 2009. It was 19% in 2021, according to the foundation's National Financial Capability Study, which surveyed 25,539 adults from June to October 2024.

The study runs every three years, so this is still its latest picture. The foundation's president, Gerri Walsh, said when it came out that it "reveals a concerning shift in Americans' financial resilience." Newer government numbers suggest the squeeze hasn't let up.

For more than a decade the numbers were steady or improving. Then they turned:

Measure20122015201820212024
Spent more than income19%18%19%19%26%
Spent less than income41%40%41%43%38%
Not at all difficult to cover bills40%48%50%54%44%
Have three months of emergency funds40%46%49%53%46%

The middle lost the most ground. Households earning $25,000 to $75,000 had the steepest fall. The share who said covering bills was not at all difficult dropped 14 points, from 52% to 38%. For households earning $75,000 or more, it fell 11 points, from 74% to 63%. For those under $25,000, it fell seven points, from 30% to 23%, from a much lower start.

Household incomeBills not at all difficultThree months of emergency fundsSpent less than income
Under $25,00023%22%29%
$25,000 to $75,00038%42%34%
$75,000 or more63%66%48%

Age matters as much as income. Only 31% of adults 18 to 34 said bills were not at all difficult, compared with 59% of people 55 and older. Financial anxiety rose to 63% of adults, from 56%, and the share satisfied with their finances fell to 24%, from 33%. About two-thirds said they had cut other spending because of food costs, and 23% had used a buy now, pay later service.

Inflation appears to be driving the decline, which reached middle- and higher-income households, FINRA Foundation researcher Olivia Valdes said on a FINRA podcast.

Where it's hardest. The foundation's state map shows a wide gap. In Ohio, Wisconsin, and Washington, more than half of adults said covering bills was not at all difficult. In West Virginia and New Mexico, about 34% did, and in Wyoming, 35%. Each state's sample is about 500 people, so small differences between states don't mean much.

What's happened since. The latest government data shows budgets are still tight. Food and housing together took 46.9% of the average household's spending in 2025, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Housing spending rose 5.8%, to $27,790 a year, and food rose 4.6%, to $10,633. Total spending rose 4.3%, to $81,905.

Americans aren't saving much of what they make. The personal saving rate was 3.8% in September, and spending rose about twice as much as income that month, $113.0 billion to $54.5 billion, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. Credit card balances reached $1.263 trillion in the second quarter, and 4.7% of household debt was in some stage of delinquency, the New York Fed reported.

Not every measure looks as grim. In the Federal Reserve's latest household survey, taken in October 2025, 73% of adults said they were doing okay or living comfortably. But 63% said they could cover a surprise $400 expense with cash or its equivalent, down from 68% in 2021, and 12% said they couldn't pay it by any means. People's expectations have soured, too: a record share recently told the University of Michigan they expected to be worse off a year from now.

If you're short every month. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's free Your Money, Your Goals toolkit has a spending tracker, a bill calendar, and a cash flow budget. The National Foundation for Credit Counseling, at 877-360-6322, connects people with certified nonprofit counselors who can set up debt management plans. And 211 can point you to local help with rent, utilities, and food.

Sources

Frequently asked

What percent of Americans spend more than they earn?

In the FINRA Foundation's latest National Financial Capability Study, 26% of adults said they spent more than their income in the past year, up from 19% in 2021. It was the highest share since the study began in 2009.

Who is struggling most to pay bills?

Lower-income and younger adults have the hardest time, but middle earners lost the most ground. Among households making $25,000 to $75,000, those saying bills were not at all difficult fell from 52% to 38% between 2021 and 2024.

How much of a household budget goes to food and housing?

Food and housing together made up 46.9% of average household spending in 2025, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Housing averaged $27,790 a year and food $10,633, for a total of $81,905 in overall spending.