If Caller ID says it's the police and you missed jury duty, it's most likely a scam
Safety

If Caller ID says it's the police and you missed jury duty, it's most likely a scam

Angie Beebe
Angie Beebe
·

See more PinScene stories in your Google results.

Losses to government impersonators nearly doubled last year to almost $800 million. This fall's version uses real police phone numbers.

The call looks real. The caller ID shows your local police department or sheriff's office, the person on the line has your name and address, and they say you missed jury duty and there's a warrant out for your arrest. To make it go away, you need to pay a fine right now.

It's a scam, and police departments across the country spent October warning about it. In Owasso, Oklahoma, police said the calls were coming from spoofed numbers that appear to belong to law enforcement, including their own, and that the callers demand payment to dismiss the warrant, KTUL reported. Police in Sumter, South Carolina, reported a spike in calls demanding cryptocurrency for missed jury duty, some backed by AI-made flyers showing a fake warrant. Similar warnings came from Flushing Township, Michigan, Normandy Park, Washington, DeSoto County, Mississippi, and Barnstable, Massachusetts, where police said scammers were using residents' names, dates of birth, and addresses.

It costs people real money. In Early, Texas, a caller posing as a county sheriff's deputy told a resident they had missed federal jury duty and faced a $7,000 fine and arrest warrants. The victim was told not to call the sheriff's office and instead to buy two MoneyPak cards loaded with $490 each, police said, according to Brownwood News. Another resident got an email claiming there was a warrant and demanding more than $38,000 for bond.

A fast-growing scam. Americans filed 32,424 complaints about government impersonation with the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center in 2025, nearly double the 17,367 in 2024, and reported losing almost $798 million, up from $406 million, according to the FBI's annual report. People 60 and older lost $413 million of that. In a September public service announcement, the FBI said it had received nearly 61,000 complaints about law enforcement or government impersonation from January 2025 through July 2026, with losses of more than $1.6 billion. Of those, 6,833 involved jury duty and warrant scams, with losses of nearly $36 million.

How it works. Scammers fake the caller ID, a trick called spoofing, to show a number you already trust, the FCC says. They may give real officers' names, badge numbers, and the names of actual federal judges, the U.S. Marshals Service warned. Then they keep up the pressure. The FBI says scammers try to keep victims on the phone the whole time and urge them not to tell family, friends, their bank, or police. They ask for payment by gift card, prepaid card, payment app, wire transfer, courier, or cash fed into a crypto ATM.

A related version targets relatives. In West Memphis, Arkansas, police said scammers spoofed the department's number to tell people someone they know had been arrested and needed bond money through Cash App. After getting paid, they sometimes called back to say the bond had gone up.

The tells. Real courts and police don't work this way. The Federal Trade Commission puts it simply: "Courts never demand payment over the phone. In fact, no government agency will." Most contact from a federal court about jury service comes by mail, according to the federal judiciary, and the courts don't ask for sensitive information by phone or email. The Warren County, Ohio, sheriff's office told residents that officers "will never offer to dismiss or fix a warrant in exchange for money," The Eagle reported.

What to do. Hang up. Don't call back a number the caller gives you. Look up the department's number on its official website and call it yourself, the FCC and police advise. If the call was about federal jury duty, contact the clerk of the U.S. District Court in your area. Report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and ic3.gov, and to your local police.

If you already paid, act fast, the FTC says. For a gift card, call the card company using the number on the back, tell them a scammer got the card number and PIN, and keep the card and receipt. For a crypto ATM, contact the ATM operator, report the transaction as fraud, and ask for it to be reversed. For a payment app or wire transfer, report it to the company right away. The same advice applies to the unpaid toll text scam.

Sources

Frequently asked

Do police call you about missing jury duty?

No. Courts usually contact jurors by mail, and the FTC says courts never demand payment over the phone. A call threatening arrest for missed jury duty unless you pay is a scam, even if the caller ID shows your police department.

How do scammers make calls look like they come from the police?

They use spoofing, which fakes the number shown on your caller ID. The FCC says scammers spoof numbers of agencies people trust. Hang up and call the department yourself using the number on its official website.

What should I do if I paid a jury duty scammer?

Contact whoever handled the payment right away: the gift card company, crypto ATM operator, payment app, or wire service. Report it as fraud and ask for a refund. Then file reports with local police, ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and ic3.gov.